Hi, I’m Mim! I’m a planning-obsessed, Award-Winning Online Business Owner, Author and 5-Star Planner Sticker Seller.
I help new sticker makers create planner stickers from scratch that stand out and sell … even if you’ve never made a sticker before!

7 Tips for Choosing the Best Sticker Paper for Planner Stickers

Hello, my sticker-loving friend! Let’s dive into the world of printable sticker paper and choosing the best sticker paper for planner stickers can make all the difference in achieving professional-looking results.

Maybe you’re looking for the best sticker paper for Cricut, Silhouette, Canva or other stickers?

From smooth finishes to adhesive strengths, this comprehensive guide will equip you with the tips and tricks you need to select the perfect paper for your sticker-making adventures. So, let’s embark on a paper journey and unlock the secrets of sticker success!

Paper Planner Club Stickers Etsy

What is Sticker Paper?

Sticker paper helps us to create stickers at home to use in our planners and other places! It transforms digital designs into tangible, peel-and-stick wonders. I’m going to help you choose the best paper for making stickers.

It comes in various types, thicknesses, and finishes, each with its own unique characteristics and purposes. We’re going to dive into all of this in more detail in this post.

Sticker paper is typically coated on one side with a layer of adhesive, allowing you to stick the paper onto surfaces such as paper, plastic, glass, or even metal. The adhesive side is protected by a peel-off backing, which is removed before applying the sticker. This backing keeps the adhesive layer clean and prevents accidental sticking before you’re ready.

How to Choose the Best Sticker Paper for Planner Stickers

Planner stickers are more than just a passing phase – they’ve become an essential tool for organizing and pretty-up our lives! They add color, style, and functionality to our planners, making our schedules and goals a joy to behold.

However, I’m always asked from people how to choose the best sticker paper for selling stickers or making them for yourself – and I hope this guide helps.

The best paper for stickers can make all the difference in achieving professional-looking results. So, let’s explore why it’s crucial to choose the right full sheet sticker paper for your planner stickers!

When choosing the best paper for printing stickers, you’ll want to look for:

1. A High Print Quality

When choosing the best printable sticker paper for Cricut or other stickers, it’s essential to achieve a high print quality. Different types of good sticker paper are designed to interact with inkjet or laser printers in specific ways. Using the appropriate paper for your printer ensures that the ink is absorbed properly, resulting in vibrant colors and sharp details. A high-quality print adds a touch of professionalism to your planner stickers, making them visually appealing and enhancing your overall planner experience. I’ll share soon my best sticker paper for inkjet printer users.

2. Durability of the Stickers

Planner stickers are meant to withstand the test of time, surviving the daily wear and tear of handling, peeling, and sticking. Choosing the right sticker paper ensures the durability and longevity of your stickers. Factors such as thickness, adhesive strength, and resistance to water or fading all contribute to the durability of your stickers. By selecting a paper that can withstand repeated use, you can ensure that your planner stickers remain intact and looking fresh for as long as you need them.

3. Paper that Cuts Easily

The right sticker paper facilitates easy cutting and precise results – super important for sticker makers like us! Different papers have varying thicknesses and cutting properties, which can affect the ease of cutting with a craft knife or a cutting machine. Thicker papers may require more pressure, while thinner papers may tear or curl easily. By choosing a sticker paper that is compatible with your cutting tools and techniques, you can achieve clean and precise cuts, resulting in professional-looking stickers that are easy to handle and apply.

4. Stickiness!

A crucial aspect of planner stickers is their ability to adhere securely to your planner pages or other surfaces. The choice of sticker paper directly impacts the adhesion of your stickers. Some papers come with removable adhesive, allowing you to reposition stickers without leaving residue or damaging surfaces. Others have permanent adhesive that ensures a strong bond, making them suitable for long-term use. By selecting the right adhesive strength for your specific needs, you can ensure that your stickers stay put while still having the flexibility to make changes when necessary.

5. Customization Ability

Every sticker enthusiast has a unique vision for their planner stickers. Choosing the right sticker paper allows you to personalize and customize your stickers according to your preferences. Whether you prefer a matte finish for a subtle and refined look, a glossy finish for vibrant and eye-catching stickers, or clear paper for a seamless, “no-edge” appearance, the paper you choose contributes to the overall aesthetics and customization options of your planner stickers. It enables you to bring your creative ideas to life and add a personal touch to your planning journey.

Now you have a strong understanding of why it’s important to pick the right sticker paper for your planner stickers, let’s look at the different options you have.

Here are some of the most popular planner sticker paper types you can choose from and how to choose.

Printable Dusk Weekly Kit of printable planner stickers for the Erin Condren Life Planner or most other planners! Get the best planner stickers and printable stickers in my best planner stickers range. #plannerstickers #freeprintables #printableplannerstickers #weeklykit #weeklystickers #etsystickers #erincondrenstickers #planning #lovefrommim #paperplannerclub

1. Consider Printable Sticker Paper Types

There are several types of sticker paper available, each with its own unique characteristics. Here are a few common options to consider:

a) Matte Sticker Paper:

Matte paper offers a non-glossy finish that is perfect for a more subtle and refined look. It works well with a variety of inkjet printers and is often easy to write on with pens or markers. This is one of my fave sticker papers!

b) Glossy Sticker Paper

If you’re after a vibrant and glossy look, this is the way to go. Glossy paper provides a shiny and polished appearance, giving your stickers a professional and eye-catching appeal.

c) Clear Sticker Paper

Clear paper creates a transparent background, making your stickers blend seamlessly onto different surfaces. This type of paper is great for achieving a “no-edge” or “die-cut” sticker effect.

d) Vinyl Sticker Paper

Vinyl paper is known for its durability and water-resistant properties. It’s ideal for stickers that need to withstand wear and tear, making it perfect for outdoor or long-lasting applications.

2. Assess Thickness and Durability

The thickness of your sticker paper plays a crucial role in its durability and how well it adheres to surfaces.

Thicker paper tends to be sturdier and less prone to tearing or curling, but it may require more pressure to cut cleanly. On the other hand, thinner paper can offer more flexibility and easier cutting, but it may be less durable in the long run.

Consider the level of durability you require for your stickers and choose a paper thickness that suits your needs.

Kiss Cut Stickers

3. Test Print Compatibility

Before committing to a specific sticker paper, it’s essential to test its compatibility with your printer.

Some printers may perform better with certain types or brands of paper. Print a test sheet to evaluate how well the paper interacts with your printer, including color accuracy, ink absorption, and overall print quality. This will help you avoid frustration and ensure consistent results when printing your stickers.

4. Adhesive Strength Matters

Sticker adhesion is a critical factor to consider, especially if you’re planning to use your stickers in a variety of applications.

Adhesive strength can vary among different sticker papers, ranging from removable to permanent options.

Removable adhesive allows for repositioning and leaves no residue, making it suitable for planners or surfaces you may want to change frequently.

Permanent adhesive provides a strong bond that can withstand longer-term use on various surfaces.

Consider the intended purpose and longevity of your stickers when choosing the adhesive strength that best suits your needs.

5. Take the Printing Method into Account

The printing method you plan to use also influences your choice of sticker paper.

Inkjet printers are commonly used for printing planner stickers, and many sticker papers are specifically designed for inkjet sticker paper printing.

Ensure that the paper you select is compatible with your printer type, as not all papers work well with laser printers or other printing methods.

Using the correct paper for your printer will ensure optimal print quality and prevent any technical issues.

An example of Mim Jenkinson's planner stickers

6. Explore Brand and Customer Reviews

When in doubt, turn to the experiences and recommendations of other sticker enthusiasts. Explore different brands of sticker paper and read customer reviews to gain insights into their quality, performance, and overall satisfaction.

Pay attention to feedback on color vibrancy, adhesive strength, and ease of cutting. This information can help you make an informed decision and avoid potential disappointments.

7. Experiment and Have Fun

Sticker-making is an art, and the journey to finding the perfect paper is an adventure.

Embrace the experimentation process and don’t be afraid to try different papers until you find the one that ticks all the boxes for your specific needs.

Sometimes the best way to discover the perfect paper is through hands-on experience. So, grab a variety pack, unleash your creativity, and let the sticker paper exploration begin!

Summary of Choosing the Best Planner Sticker Paper

Selecting the right paper for your planner stickers is a vital step in achieving the desired results.

By considering factors such as paper type, thickness, print compatibility, adhesive strength, and customer reviews, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your creative vision.

Don’t be afraid to experiment with different sticker papers and explore the wide range of options available.

With the perfect paper in hand, your planner stickers will come to life with vibrant colors, durability, and a professional finish. So, embrace the sticker paper journey, let your creativity soar, and get ready to make sticker magic!

Free Class for Future Sticker Makers

Ready to get started? Click here to watch my FREE class about the perfect plan to make planner stickers!


  • Get the simple plan for perfect planner stickers … without feeling overwhelmed by the process
  • Avoid the 3 BIG mistakes new sticker makers make (including some personal ones I made!)
  • Know which essential tools and equipment you need to have to get started (that I love, use and recommend)
  • Use your creativity to come up with endless sticker design ideas
  • Learn my outline overview for designing planner stickers in minutes (including design, print and cut hacks!) and how you can get started with me


Free Masterclass - The Sticker Making Mistakes to Avoid
Free Masterclass – The Sticker Making Mistakes to Avoid

Make your Own Planner Stickers to Sell!

Want to get started today creating your own stickers for yourself … or to sell?

You can, when you join The Sticker Shop Plan eCourse!

After taking this course, you’ll know how about making stickers to sell on Etsy in a fun, profit-focused sticker shop.

I’ll show you how to get awesome sticker ideas out of your head (and your heart) and into your planner … and the hands of customers who are just waiting for your stickers to brighten their days.


The Sticker Shop Plan eCourse by Mim Jenkinson

Read next:

I hope you’re feeling inspired now you have these tips for the best sticker paper for planner stickers!


I hope you enjoy learning how to make planner stickers or how to start a sticker business!

I’ve been making and selling stickers for journals and planners since 2017 and it’s become a wonderful and creative way to turn my hobby into a side hustle, then full-time online business.

Whether you want to make Cricut stickers, Silhouette stickers or you’re starting from complete scratch, you’re in the right place. Making planner stickers can be for you, or to start an Etsy sticker shop and sell stickers online and you don’t need any previous experience to get started.

Want to make planner stickers from home? Check out my sticker making courses, eBooks and other products here!

I acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of the land I work and live on, the Awabakal peoples, and pay my respects to Elders past and present.
I thank them wholeheartedly and express my love and gratitude for the privilege to live and work in such a beautiful part of the world and for the opportunity for my family to be part of this vibrant and supportive community.